A 2018 review in The Gospel Coalition journal Themelios critiqued Simmonss translation process, specifically his overuse of double translation, bringing in multiple meanings of a word even if it wasnt clear that wordplay was intended. This sort of thing is not limited It positions you and me within proven, godly wisdom and gives precious insight into the heart, nature, and goodness of God. From the preface to this old, but precise translation: The original edition of this Commentary - in Latin, like the lectures on which it was based - was prepared for the press by George Rrer, one of Luther's most assiduous and reliable reporters, with some assistance from Veit Dietrich and more from Caspar . Reading through these letters is like having Paul sit in the living room and share his experiences and message of life. The Greek text does not itself contain this thought. One of these is yielded up: J. Payne Smith (Mrs Margoliouth)does give the meaning yield, surrender for the word in the peal form, but only as the ninth in her list (i), after the meanings agree with, agree to, follow, follow after, correspond [to], resemble. True faith in Christ inspires a confident hope of acceptance ( ) before God. Even The Messageamong the top 10 best-selling Bible versions in the worldhas gotten dinged over the years by pastors and scholars alike for what it adds, misses, or rewords. (AE), 19The acts of the flesh are obvious: sexual immorality,(AF) impurity and debauchery; 20idolatry and witchcraft; hatred, discord, jealousy, fits of rage, selfish ambition, dissensions, factions 21and envy; drunkenness, orgies, and the like. 8That kind of persuasion does not come from the one who calls you. (AO) 25Since we live by the Spirit,(AP) let us keep in step with the Spirit. Antrim County election: did the County Clerk misinform the Oversight Committee about the identity of the software? The number of Bible resources is growing, and theyre becoming more accessible to the average reader through digital platforms like Bible Gateway, YouVersion, and Logos. Galatians 1:1 The name Paul means "little.". The idea of freedom seems to be his own. ancestor of Christ in Matthew 1:10, and does not describe Jesus as Marys firstborn First released as a New Testament in 2017, The Passion Translation includes additions that do not appear in the source manuscripts, phrases meant to draw out Gods tone and heart in each passage. I do New Living Translation Those who belong to Christ Jesus have nailed the passions and desires of their sinful nature to his cross and crucified them there. But Bible scholars, including those who translated the NIV, use a more rigorous standard. The Passion Translation (TPT) is listed as no longer available among the sites 90 English-language Bible offerings. Is that true? But in both philosophy of translation and actual practice, it is a paraphrase. was put to death on the cross and crucified with Messiah. 7You were running a good race. (AA) 17For the flesh desires what is contrary to the Spirit, and the Spirit what is contrary to the flesh. Peter Gurry, New Testament professor at Phoenix Seminary, said its not surprising that any new Bible project would want to position itself as both trustworthy and better than whats available already. Whats unique about The Passion Stay tuned to my channel for more info on this in the coming weeks.0:00 How Simmons secret revelation led to my Passion Project.1:43 My disclaimer.2:36 Who is Dr. Gupta and why is he reviewing Galatians?4:19 Brian Simmons claims to have supernatural secrets.5:53 Simmons claims TPT is a translation but it is NOT.8:23 The difference between official use and supplementary Bibles.10:51 TPT web site misleads people.14:38 Does it seem like TPT has gone through the normal scholarly reviews before publishing?17:02 Outrageous claims Simmons is making about TPT.20:39 Does Dr. Gupta think Brian Simmons is qualified to make a translation?22:08 Unusual decisions in TPT.22:37 What Dr. Gupta find MOST TROUBLING about TPT (hint: Aramaic).31:44 Should we just use TPT as a supplementary/secondary Bible?33:22 Me and Dr. Gupta discuss The Message Bible briefly.35:01 TPT is a lot like a Targum.37:28 What positive choices were made in TPT?39:02 TPT handles the word religion in unusual ways.40:49 TPT uses legalism in unusual ways.41:02 TPT does confusing things with the word faith.41:56 Slave is mistranslated in a most egregious way. We must always cherish this truth and stubbornly refuse to go back into the bondage of our past., Every spiritual blessing in the heavenly realm has already been lavished upon us as a love gift from our wonderful heavenly Father, the Father of our Lord Jesus all because he sees us wrapped into Christ. Scriptures are inaccurate., Its finally possible to interpret the Download Galatians Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle. Readers are encouraged to explore the embedded links in this post to find additional resources. grocery store and everyone he met collapsed onto the floor, in reallife only a few Greek manuscripts omit this word, prophets who It cannot mean yield to here, which is further evidence that it does not mean yield to in Galatians 5.25. been improved in this passage. What's in this chapter? View all posts by Andrew Chapman, Your email address will not be published. Literally there is no law set against these things or there is no conflict with Jewish laws., Keep in mind that we who belong to Jesus Christ have already experienced crucifixion. In the plural, as here, with the lamadh prefix as sign of the direct or indirect object, it can mean in the footsteps, as does in Greek. As of July 2022, it appears that the videos to which there are several links embedded in the post, in which some of Brian Simmons' outlandish claims are made, have disappeared. Manifest your kingdom on earth. Introduction, One Gospel, & How Paul Became An Apostle YOUTUBE BIBLE: Did you know that you can. The Passion Translation contrasts this approachwhere translations are done by necessity by individuals or small teams, whose main goal is to transfer the essential meaning of the textwith traditional translation work, which involves a broader committee of experts. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. But the fruit produced by the Holy Spirit within you is divine love in all its varied expressions: He wrote that he doesnt recommend it, objects to the publishers advice to use it from the pulpit, and urges leaders to clarify that its not a translation. Martin Luther . First Corinthians 14:34 has been mangled: So far I have only described The Forgive our sins as we ourselves release forgiveness to those who have wronged us. The NAR also teaches that prophets The Lords Prayer in Luke 11, for example, is printed in red as Jesus words and reads: Our heavenly Father, may the glory of your name be the center on which our life turns. https://www.bible.com/bible/1849/GAL.5.22-23.TPT, Need Some Self-Control? While serving as missionaries in the 1980s, Simmons and his wife helped develop a new Bible translation for an unreached people group in Central America. In many ways, Galatians 5:1 is a great summary of everything Paul wanted the Galatians to understand: Christ has liberated us to be free. Mike Winger, a Calvary Chapeltrained pastor who teaches through his online ministry Bible Thinker, has drawn in over one million YouTube views with a series examining The Passion Translation. Whoever wrote this fiction challenges any explanation other than lies or mental illness. Subscribe to our newsletter stay up-to-date with the latest concerts, contests, news, and local happenings! dat-si-fem. ), mangling of Ephesians 5:22; inasmuch as Alexander put, The original language of the (AB) They are in conflict with each other, so that you are not to do whatever[c] you want. All that matters now is living in the faith that works and expresses itself through love. Both Aramaic and Greek manuscripts read biting and devouring, which is a metaphor for critical attitudes that will destroy the fellowship. Perhaps the most distinctive feature of his rendering is the idea of surrendering and yielding to the Spirit. So may we never be arrogant, or look down on another. We must forsake all jealousy that diminishes the value of others. As a militant Muslim, I never expected to have any dealings with Christians, much less to befriend them. Fall in love with God all over again. 6 When you're joined to the Anointed One, circumcision and religious obligations can benefit you nothing. I've hired a number of scholars to review Brian Simmons' seriously. However, in the course of researching for this project I've uncovered some other very concerning things about Brian Simmons' teachings including false prophecy and various extreme claims regarding his own spiritual experiences. Subscribers receive full access to the archives. The Fruit of the Spirit - Galatians 5:22-23 From The Passion Translation (TPT): But the fruit produced by the Holy Spirit within you is divine love in all its varied expressions: joy that overflows, peace that subdues, patience that endures, kindness in action, a life full of virtue, faith that prevails, gentleness of heart, and strength of spirit. This sort of testimony is taken But we have the true hope that comes from being made right with God, and by the Spirit we wait eagerly for this hope. 43:47 Simmons natural realm creates a gnostic-like mistake.44:29 The cumulative effect the TPT can have on you.45:34 Artificial insertion of theology into Galatians.46:50 Didnt TPT just come out with a new 2020 edition that fixed these problems?47:08 Dr. Gupta reacts to misleading quotes from TPT website.49:10 Dr. Gupta reacts to the Bill Johnson endorsement of TPT.50:38 Is it good for TPT be in apps, websites and bookstores?51:21 What paraphrase would Dr. Gupta recommend?52:51 What can you say to someone who loves TPT?53:42 How do Simmons outrageous claims measure up to reality?56:56 Dr. Guptas final word on TPT.57:50 Plugging some other books by Dr. Gupta.58:22 We reflect on my Passion Project.1:00:11 Ive got a few announcements for you all.1:01:08 Brian Simmons false prophecy.LINK to all interviews AND papers as they are uploaded. All that matters now is living in the faith that works and expresses itself through love. by James Snapp, Jr. Verse 6 . Perfectly ordinary and legitimate He also cites four other places in the New Testament where the word translates : Notably, it is used to translate (the participle in its masculine nominative form) in Romans 4.12: . It was written by a scholar on the NIV Committee on Bible Translation, who worried that Simmonss own theology and favorite themes were driving his word choice. After returning to the US, planting a church, and leading their Bible-teaching ministry, he began to work on The Passion Translation using the skills he honed on the mission field. to lawful freedom. Devotions From Time Of Grace, The Impact and Attitude of a Faith Driven Investor, When Will God Finally Show Up? The chief concert technician for Steinway & Sons gave Bibles to the worlds greatest pianists and told them about Jesus. The goal of this translation is to trigger inside every reader an . to the. So then, the two incompatible and conflicting forces within you are your self-life of the flesh and the new creation life of the Spirit. But purging TPT of its deviations from the (Q) The one who is throwing you into confusion,(R) whoever that may be, will have to pay the penalty. Get the most recent headlines and stories from Christianity Today delivered to your inbox daily. noun (name) indeclinable. A Bible version designed to recapture the emotion of Gods Word was removed from Bible Gateway last week. The Passion [Anti-] Translation: Is Brian Simmons really translating from the Aramaic when he claims to be? foreseeing. Copyright 2002-2023 Got Questions Ministries. really, really, wants them to make sense; for instance, in a note to John 2:20, The exhortation of the Greek text (the subjunctive mood of is hortatory) is lost in Simmons version, as is the sense of progression: if we live, then let us also keep in line. The Greek word here can be translated harvest., produced by the Holy Spirit within you is divine love. Hallelujah! What's wrong with GALATIANS in The Passion Translation (Dr. Nijay Gupta) - YouTube Open description for time stamps. make false predictions are still considered prophets, http://theriveroflife.com/2017/03/23/brian-simmons-claims-to-be-translating-from-the-aramaic-the-ten-cases-in-summary/, having By using our website, you accept our use of cookies as described in our Privacy Policy. by Simmons is the time, Most God transforms us from being "important" to being "small" in our own eyes. From Lamsas surrender and Alexanders submission may come Simmons surrendered and yielding. For readers who dont know the original languages (which is, of course, most of them) you can start to form a judgment of a new translation by comparing it with those other translations that have gained a trusted readership over the years, he said. If the Spirit is the source of our life, we must also allow the Spirit to direct every aspect of our lives. Wilson first raised concerns in a 2016 blog post about TPT and continues to get asked about the version from fellow charismatics. unusual rendering: The Joyous Expectation hatred of those who get in your way, senseless arguments, resentment when others are favored, temper tantrums, angry quarrels, only thinking of yourself, being in love with your own opinions. Required fields are marked *. This same link will have ALL the reviews and papers as they are published. Stand firm then and don't submit again to a yoke of slavery. Never set the law above these qualities, for they are meant to be limitless. It appears that where the . One could argue that surrendering and yielding to the Spirit is necessary if we are to follow and stay in line with Him, but this would be a matter of interpretation, not of translation, in my opinion. I applaud the life and ministry of Brian Simmons! Is God restoring the offices of apostle and prophet in the church today. Greek text of the New Testament would be a good and necessary first step toward 2aor-act-par. Stand, then, as free people, and do not allow yourselves to become slaves again.- Good News Translation (L) Who cut in on you(M) to keep you from obeying the truth? Quotations attributed in this review to The Passion Translation are from T. Copyright 2017, 2018 by BroadStreet 4 you who are trying to be justified by the law have been alienated from christ; you have fallen away from grace. This Wall Decor item by ericamcclintock has 72 favorites from Etsy shoppers. This is the last of ten posts looking in turn at the first ten occasions, starting in 'Letters from Heaven' at Galatians its first book, when Brian Simmons claims that what he writes is 'translated from the Aramaic'. I, Paul, tell you that if you let yourselves be circumcised,(D) Christ will be of no value to you at all. More insights from your Bible study - Get Started with Logos Bible Software for Free! wild parties, and all other similar behavior. I Wanted to Die for Allah. Nestle-Aland compilation and the Byzantine Text disagree, the Aramaic text often cast a deciding vote and, as we have seen, in some cases, it for less than $4.25/month. His name before his conversion was Saul, which means "significant one" or "sought after.". Galatians 4.7 in Brian Simmons Passion [Anti-] Translation, Galatians 5.26 in Brian Simmons Passion [Anti-] Translation, The meaning of in the New Testament (resources). of Simmons abundant notes and book-introductions (which in some cases are to Matthew): Nor does it help Simmons credibility when one reads, in a Author of She Is Free, Founder of The She Is Free Conference, Co-Lead Pastor of Liberty Church, andiandrew.com, Singer-Songwriter/Worship Leader, www.jakehamiltonmusic.com, Marriage Missionaries, supernaturalmarriage.org, International Director, Healing Rooms Ministries, Bible teacher, preacher, author, and church planter, Research Associate to Frederick Danker, translator of Bauers Greek-English Lexicon, About TPT Translation Philosophy Statement of Faith, The Passion Translation is a gift to Bible readers. Bill Johnson at Bethel Church still uses the New American Standard Bible (NASB) in most of his writing and preaching due to familiarity, he said in a clip from last year titled, Is The Passion Translation Heresy? He uses TPT for devotional reading, as he did with paraphrases before it. (A) Stand firm,(B) then, and do not let yourselves be burdened again by a yoke of slavery. We so appreciate the labor of love that went into translating the Scriptures directly from the Greek, Hebrew, and Aramaic. It is equally obvious that Simmons Western Christianity, Modern Judaism, Islam, Buddhism and Hinduism. (S) In that case the offense(T) of the cross has been abolished. 1 \u0026 2 Thessalonians https://amzn.to/3akb6vM Colossians https://amzn.to/2KxJdFD A Beginners Guide to New Testament Studies https://amzn.to/2KaEV7a Philippians https://amzn.to/37sbiqV My website https://BibleThinker.org What does this imply about the validity of that deleted note? Dont you know that when you allow even a little lie into your heart, it can permeate your entire belief system? What a marvelous job my friend and seasoned leader is doing for the Body of Christ! where the Jewish leaders mention that it had taken 46 years to build the The Passion Translation (TPT) Used with permission. Your email address will not be published. temple, Simmons comments, Our bodies (temples) have forty-six chromosomes in ver 18, 25; Ro 8:2, 4-6, 9, 14; S 2Co 5:17, ver 13, 16-21; S Ro 6:6; 7:5, 18; 8:3-5, 8, 9, 12, 13; 13:14; Gal 6:8; Col 2:11, NIV, Biblical Theology Study Bible, Comfort Print: Follow Gods Redemptive Plan as It Unfolds throughout Scripture, NIV, Beautiful Word Bible Journal, Revelation, Paperback, Comfort Print, NIV, The Story, Hardcover, Comfort Print: The Bible as One Continuing Story of God and His People, NIV, Journal the Word Bible, Double-Column, Red Letter Edition, Comfort Print: Reflect, Take Notes, or Create Art Next to Your Favorite Verses, NIV, Story of Jesus: Experience the Life of Jesus as One Seamless Story, NIV, Cultural Backgrounds Study Bible, Red Letter Edition: Bringing to Life the Ancient World of Scripture. TPTs publisher, BroadStreet Publishing Group, confirmed that Bible Gateway made the disappointing decision to discontinue their license for The Passion Translation as of January 2022. Thanks for referring to my work demonstrating Simmons's reliance on Victor Alexander in many passages.I had hoped that these books by Simmons - I do not want to refer them as holy scripture - would be rejected by the body of Christ after consideration - but it seems from the endorsements by prominent Christian leaders that on the contrary that their use is spreading like a cancer. The Apostle Paul writes this bundle of letters to the first-century churches he planted. throughout The Passion Translation, because it is not just a translation; it is I live for Jesus. not mean that without the bits that have no Greek support, the TPT New But do we? Antrim County election: was the results correction completed on 5 November at 4pm, or 6 November at 10pm? An exhaustive and thorough review and update of the entire Bible will be undertaken ahead of its release in the next 5-6 years, BroadStreet said in a statement. But its author, Eugene Peterson, was clear that he was putting the Bible into his voicedescribing the project as a paraphrase, not a translation. Testament., All the articles on the Internet regarding the Original God longs to have his Word expressed in every language in a way that unlocks the passion of his heart. First released as a New Testament in 2017, The Passion Translation includes additions that do not appear in the source manuscripts, phrases meant to draw out God's "tone" and "heart" in each. Bible Gateways parent company, HarperCollins Christian Publishing, told CT, We periodically review our content, making changes as necessary, to align with our business goals. The company declined to offer further details about its reason for the decision. Galatians 5.26 Its definition of is to be in line with a person or thing considered as standard for ones conduct.). Let me be clear, the Anointed One has set us free not partially, but completely and wonderfully free! What I love about The Passion Translation, https://www.thepassiontranslation.com/testimonial/bianca-juarez-olthoff/, "Having studied New Testament in Germany on a Fulbright Scholarship, I grew to marvel at the pithiness of Martin Luthers translation (1534) of the Bible into German. Thus, the Catholic church recognizes twelve fruits: If youre interested in reading about the history of these lost fruits, read:Galatians 5:22-23: Have We Lost Some Fruit? Certain passages in TPT are twice as long as in other translations such as the NIV. Copyright 2021 Christ Lives in You Inc. a nonprofit Christian ministry organization. But Christians still have questions about how the church markets faith. His translation has been endorsed by a range of apostolic charismatic Christians, including The Calls Lou Engle, Bethels Bill Johnson, and Hillsongs Bobbie Houston. (although in his annotation on Mark 1:2, Simmons states, This line is a Antrim County election: rightleft vote transfer in nine of the sixteen precincts. (H) 6For in Christ Jesus(I) neither circumcision nor uncircumcision has any value. They are currently working on the remaining books of the Old Testament and moving forward with plans to release a full Bible edition around 2027. every cell.. These 12-week studies lead participants through books of the Bible and are made up of four basic components: (1) Reflection questions help readers engage the text at a deeper level . Start for FREE. And rescue us every time we face tribulations. Now that verse reads in an updated The Passion Translation "May the blessings of divine grace and supernatural peace that flow from God our wonderful father and our messiah, the Lord Jesus be upon your lives." This is a radical change, back towards how true translations render that verse. We must always cherish this truth and firmly refuse to go back into the bondage of our past. and firmly refuse to go back into the bondage of our past. This translation has chosen to supply action to these virtues, for they are not meant to be abstract virtues, but made visible with actions. Galatians 5:1. I'll be sharing some of this in future videos as well since I have realized that he is not just styling himself as a Bible translator but as an inspired Bible interpreter who is going to release a last days transformation in the people of God so that \"everything that can be said about Jesus can be said about you\". But that's not the only kind of church growth in the Bible.. Apart of living in fellowship with another, . Here is the Western UBS Peshitta textfromdukrhana.com with transliteration and three English translationsby Etheridge (green), Murdock (navy), and Lamsa (purple): Although Etheridge lacks the second clause, the Syriac text does contain both clauses, as the analysis tool shows: In its first occurrence, (r), breath, wind or here, spirit or Spirit, is preceded by a beth, the preposition (b), meaning in; while in its second it is preceded by a waw, the copulative conjunction , meaning and, also, and by a lamadh, the preposition , meaning to or for, which can function as the sign of either the direct or the indirect object, among other uses. 3Again I declare to every man who lets himself be circumcised that he is obligated to obey the whole law. The purpose of this book is to give the origin of all things, including the cosmic order of the universe and the covenant relationship between God and his people. While no explanation was given, BroadStreet Publishing accepts that Bible Gateway has the right to make decisions as they see fit with the platforms they manage, BroadStreet said in a statement. Never set the law above these qualities, for they are meant to be limitless. The yeast is the lie of legalism. For all the law can be summarized in one grand statement: Demonstrate love to your neighbor, even as you care for and love yourself.. (C), 2Mark my words! 2 Peter 2:1 Now there were also false prophets among the people, just as there will be false teachers among . People say, Do you feel qualified? I say, Who in the world is? My qualifications are that I was told to do this from the Lord. The Knowing the Bible series is a resource designed to help Bible readers better understand and apply God's Word. you.. These terms were often found in classical Greek literature to describe wild animals fighting each other in deadly conflict. Dear friends, why do you think the religious system persecutes me? patience that endures, This 12-lesson study guide on the book of Galatians provides a unique and welcoming opportunity to immerse yourself in God's precious Word as expressed in The Passion Translation(R). A new version must closely adhere to the wording, syntax, and structure of its source. 3 again i declare to every man who lets himself be circumcised that he is obligated to obey the whole law. Through The Passion Translation of Pauls letters from heaven you will sense the stirring of the Holy Spirit as he reveals the heart of God for your life in him. Havent I already warned you that those who use their freedom for these things will not inherit the kingdom realm of God! Galatians 5:1. If the same material was marketed as a "commentary" or as a "study guide," it would still be concerning. did not consistently follow the Byzantine Text, for he turns Amos into an 13You, my brothers and sisters, were called to be free. As it is, The Passion Translation cannot honestly be called a translation or even a paraphrase. $100M Ad Campaign Aims to Make Jesus the Biggest Brand in Your City, Died: Jack Hayford, Pentecostal Pastor Who Wrote Majesty, Federal Judge Tosses Challenge to Christian College Exemptions, The 50 Countries Where Its Most Dangerous to Follow Jesus in 2021, Recant or Leave: Mobs Expel Christians in Central India, Authorized: The Use and Misuse of the King James Bible. The message of Gods story is timeless; the Word of God doesnt change. Simmons draws his competence into Here I look at Galatians 5.26. Whatever he tells you to do, he will meet the need you have to finish it.. For inspiration, I love The Passion Translation, the Bethel founder said. We must always cherish this truth and firmly refuse to go back into the bondage of our past. Toxic I've hired a number of scholars to review Brian Simmons' seriously flawed Bible version. Sign up for our newsletter: Would we be able to fully understand his message, or would some of it puzzle us? Simmons, Passion 'Translation': Note b: By referring to 'this very unusual sentence', Simmons clearly marks his endnote as applying to the last sentence of his rendering of Galatians 3.1: 'Wasn't he revealed to you as the Manifestation of Wisdom?' He says that it 'is translated from the Aramaic text'. Just didnt have the same bite and passion of Luther. Before you were led astray, you were so faithful. For dedicated TPT readers, the new phrasing and the emotive power of the text are major draws. For more on my purpose and methodology seehereandhere. Were trying to discover, communicate, and release Gods heart through the words we choose.. Bible Gateway removing TPT after reviewing the work in more detail is a signal to everyone that the work may have issues, he said. Some of the most beautiful truths of all the Bible are found in Pauls letters: Ephesians lays an exciting foundation for our lives; Philippians fills our hearts with joy; Colossians brings the colossal revelation of Christ in us, the hope of glory; and Pauls letters to his spiritual son Timothy stir our hearts with greater passion to serve God and love him supremely. But dont view this wonderful freedom as an excuse to set up a base of operations in the natural realm. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. What great transformation takes place when we experience a profound change like Saul did! A COMMENTARY ON SAINT PAUL 'S EPISTLE TO THE GALATIANS 1535 . 22But the fruit(AI) of the Spirit is love,(AJ) joy, peace,(AK) forbearance, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, 23gentleness and self-control.